Was California's Rate Approval Process for Your Premiums Even Legal?

While California's largest insurers were winning double-digit homeowners rate increases in 2026, the judge responsible for independently reviewing those deals says she was fired for insisting the law be followed.

Was California's Rate Approval Process for Your Premiums Even Legal?

While California's largest insurers were winning double-digit homeowners rate increases in 2026, the judge responsible for independently reviewing those deals says she was fired for insisting the law be followed.

A bombshell lawsuit now puts the entire California insurance rate approval process under a legal microscope. As first reported by Insurance Business, Kristin Rosi, the former chief administrative law judge for the California Department of Insurance, filed suit in Alameda County Superior Court in late September 2026, alleging she was pressured to change her rulings and then terminated when she refused. The Save Max Quote Index, drawn from 3.3 million+ real quote requests, consistently shows California among the most expensive states for personal lines coverage, and this lawsuit may help explain part of why rates climbed so steeply in recent years. For a deeper look at how California stacks up, see our California Auto Insurance guide.

Were California's recent insurance rate increases approved legally?

The short answer, according to Rosi's lawsuit, is: possibly not.

Rosi served as the department's top administrative law judge from 2016 until her firing in 2025. She alleges that Commissioner Ricardo Lara and his former special counsel Lucy Wang pressured her to reverse rulings she had made consistent with California law. When she refused, she was fired. The suit was filed in Alameda County Superior Court and was first reported by CalMatters before Insurance Business covered it nationally.

The core allegation is damaging: some of the rate increases California policyholders are now paying may have been approved through a process that skipped the independent judicial review state law requires. That is not a minor procedural quibble. It goes to the legitimacy of every rate hike approved through the contested settlement mechanism.

The California Department of Insurance declined to comment on the lawsuit.

What Proposition 103 requires, and what Rosi says was skipped

Proposition 103 is the 1988 ballot measure that governs how California insurance rates are set. Its core requirement is straightforward: rate increases need prior approval from the department before they take effect.

When a consumer group formally requests a hearing on a proposed increase, the department must hold one before approving the rate. The hearing is supposed to be presided over by an independent administrative law judge, or ALJ, who reviews whether the proposed increase is justified and fair.

Rosi's October 2024 ruling concluded that even when insurers and the department reached negotiated settlements on rate increases, those settlements still required independent judicial sign-off to confirm they were fair. That review, she found, was not optional. It was mandated by Proposition 103 itself.

The department's Rate Enforcement Bureau disagreed, arguing Rosi's decision contained legal errors. Lara partially vacated her ruling on that basis. That is the moment, according to the lawsuit, when the pressure campaign against Rosi began in earnest.

How the rate-settlement shortcut worked in practice

Here is what the challenged process actually looked like on the ground.

Instead of going through a full public ALJ hearing, the department and insurers negotiated rate settlements directly. Those settlements allowed double-digit homeowners rate increases for several of the state's largest carriers to move forward without the delays that full public hearings historically entailed.

Rosi's objection was not that settlements are inherently improper. Her ruling was that they still had to clear an independent judicial review before taking effect. Without that step, the process cut out the neutral check that Proposition 103 was designed to guarantee.

"An [administrative law judge] calls balls and strikes... they wanted the [insurance] industry to win almost all the time." Robert Herrell, executive director of the Consumer Federation of California

Herrell, a former deputy commissioner under Lara's predecessor Dave Jones, made those remarks to CalMatters. They capture the central concern: that the settlement process, as implemented, was structured to favor insurers rather than produce neutral outcomes.

The E&S market's growth in California has been partly a function of the admitted market's regulatory constraints, with carriers exiting or restricting coverage in high-risk areas while awaiting rate approvals. The Rosi lawsuit adds a new dimension to that story: not just whether rates are adequate, but whether the process that approved them had the independent oversight the law requires.

Key players, timeline, and alleged pressure campaign

October 2024Rosi issues ruling that ALJ review is required for negotiated rate settlements
Late 2024 / Early 2025Lara partially vacates the ruling; Wang and senior officials begin limiting what cases the Administrative Hearing Bureau can take up
2025Lara emails Rosi directly, asking her to "get on board" with a narrower scope for judicial review
2025Rosi is fired; she files complaints with the California State Bar against Wang and three other department officials
Late September 2026Rosi files suit in Alameda County Superior Court
August 2026The department's one remaining ALJ issues a ruling alluding to an understaffed and underresourced judicial branch
November 3, 2026Jane Kim declared victory in the election to succeed Lara as commissioner
February 16, 2027First case management conference in the lawsuit is scheduled

The alleged pressure was direct. The lawsuit states that Lara emailed Rosi personally, asking her to accept a plan under which judges could only review settlements in rate proceedings once a formal notice of hearing had already been issued. That would have significantly narrowed independent oversight.

Rosi also filed complaints with the California State Bar against Wang and three other department officials, alleging that Wang and, in at least one instance, Lara met privately with the department's legal team about cases pending before those same lawyers, without including all parties such as insurers and intervenors. In a court proceeding, that kind of one-sided communication with a decision-maker is treated as improper ex parte communication.

Wang now works for a San Francisco law firm representing insurance companies. She told CalMatters she could not comment on the litigation, as she was being represented by the attorney general's office in her official capacity. The attorney general's office deferred to the Insurance Department.

What the department and outgoing commissioner say, and what comes next

The California Department of Insurance declined to comment.

That silence is notable given the seriousness of the allegations. Dave Jones, Lara's predecessor and the official who originally appointed Rosi, did not stay quiet.

"Shocking and disturbing." Dave Jones, former California Insurance Commissioner, describing the lawsuit's allegations to CalMatters

Jones told CalMatters the commissioner is supposed to be walled off from the rest of the department when a matter comes before him as final decision-maker. His comments suggest the alleged conduct, if proven, would represent a fundamental breakdown of the department's internal governance.

The Administrative Hearing Bureau now has just one judge. That judge, in a ruling in August 2026, alluded to an understaffed and underresourced judicial branch, a detail that underscores how much institutional capacity has eroded.

Jane Kim, who declared victory in the November 3 election to succeed Lara, said through a spokesperson that she plans to investigate Rosi's claims as soon as she takes office in January. The first case management conference in the lawsuit is scheduled for February 16, 2027.

What this means for you

If you are a California policyholder paying higher auto or home insurance premiums approved through the settlement mechanism Rosi challenged, the legitimacy of that process is now an open legal question. Review your renewal notices carefully and note any rate increases that took effect in 2024 or 2025. Watch for developments when Kim takes office in January and when the February 16, 2027 case management conference occurs. The SMQI will continue tracking California quote trends so you can benchmark your own rate against what other drivers in the state are actually paying. If your premiums have spiked, compare quotes now using multiple carriers rather than accepting your renewal as the market rate.

Key terms explained

Proposition 103: The 1988 California ballot measure that requires insurers to get prior approval from the state Department of Insurance before raising rates. It was designed to protect consumers from excessive premium increases.

Administrative Law Judge (ALJ): An independent judicial officer who presides over regulatory hearings. In the insurance context, an ALJ reviews whether a proposed rate increase meets legal standards and is fair to policyholders. The department's ALJ bureau now reportedly has only one judge.

Ex parte communication: One-sided communication between a party in a proceeding and the decision-maker, without the other parties present. It is prohibited in adjudicative proceedings because it undermines neutrality. Rosi's State Bar complaints allege this occurred when Wang and Lara met with the department's legal team about pending cases.

Excess and Surplus (E&S) market: A segment of the insurance market that operates outside standard regulatory requirements. Carriers in the E&S market can price risk more freely but are subject to fewer consumer protections. California's admitted market instability, driven partly by rate approval delays, has pushed more coverage into the E&S market.

FAQ

Can a California rate increase be reversed if the approval process was flawed?

Who is Kristin Rosi and why does her lawsuit matter?

What is Proposition 103 and how does it protect California policyholders?

Who is Jane Kim and what has she promised to do about this?

How does this affect California auto insurance specifically?

About Taleah McGuire

Taleah McGuire is a Regional Analyst at Save Max Auto with 11+ years of insurance experience including senior roles at Kentucky Farm Bureau. She covers regulatory news, state-specific reform legislation, and traditional carrier coverage. Read more from Taleah McGuire →

Edited by Kyle Greenwood.

Methodology

This article is grounded in the source linked above. Save Max Auto data points referenced here are drawn from the Save Max Quote Index (SMQI), a proprietary instrument reflecting 3,364,317 real consumer quote requests submitted to savemaxauto.com. State and carrier rankings reflect the lifetime dataset; year-over-year shifts reflect a rolling 12-month window. The index is refreshed monthly. External authority figures referenced (NAIC, NHTSA, state regulators) reflect the most recent public data releases available at time of writing.

Sources

  • Primary source: Insurance Business, "California judge alleges she was fired for ruling against insurer settlements"