vehicles
Published: Oct 7, 2026
Key Takeaways
A Ford Explorer costs about $2,656 a year to insure — for one specific driver
Published Explorer estimates range from $1,596 to $2,656 a year. That 66% spread is not disagreement about the vehicle. It is seven publishers pricing seven different drivers on seven different policies.
- Full coverage runs about $2,656 a year, liability-only about $1,068. The full-coverage figure prices a 40-year-old with a clean record and good credit on 100/300/100 limits and a $500 deductible.
- Four things explain almost the whole spread. Coverage level, deductible, liability limits, and the age of the driver being quoted. Match those before you compare two numbers.
- Where you park it matters more than which trim you bought. The same Explorer and the same driver cost $4,508 a year in Louisiana and $1,555 in Hawaii.
- The Explorer sits mid-pack against other SUVs. Priced on one publisher's identical profile it lands fourth of eight — above the Escape and Edge, below the Highlander, Grand Cherokee, Bronco and Telluride.
- Shopping at renewal is the cheapest lever you have. Owners who shop annually save up to 24% against those who let a policy auto-renew. It costs nothing to do.
2020 is the year to look at twice. It carries 33 recall campaigns, the most of any model year, and it is also where published rate estimates disagree most. IIHS notes structural changes after May 2020, so the build date matters as much as the model year.
A Ford Explorer costs about $2,656 a year to insure with full coverage — roughly $221 a month. That price describes one specific driver: 40 years old, clean record, good credit, 100/300/100 liability limits and a $500 deductible, per Insure.com's April 2026 figures. Drop to liability-only, and it falls to around $1,068.
Ask the same question of a different site, though, and you'll get a different answer. Published Explorer averages run from $1,596 to $2,656 — a 66% spread for one vehicle. Coverage level accounts for much of it: compare full coverage against full coverage, and the range tightens to $1,788 to $2,656, still 49%. What's left comes down to three things nobody puts in a headline — the deductible, the liability limits, and how old the driver being quoted is.
So we pulled all seven publishers and put every figure next to the driver it actually prices. Below you'll find the Explorer's cost by model year, by trim, by state, and by driver profile, along with which insurers come out cheapest and what actually brings the number down. For other models, browse our vehicle insurance hub.
Why Explorer Insurance Estimates Vary So Much
The first rule when comparing insurance prices is simple: make sure you are comparing the same product. The table below puts each published Explorer figure alongside the driver profile, coverage level, deductible, and methodology reported by the source.
Why the Estimates Differ
Seven publishers, seven different drivers
Every figure below is for a Ford Explorer. The spread is not disagreement about the vehicle — it is seven publishers pricing seven different policies.
| Source | Published cost | What it covers | Who it prices | Updated |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Insurify | $1,596$133/mo | BlendedAll coverage types, $1,000 deductible | Ages 20–70, clean record, credit 600+ | Aug 2026 |
| MoneyGeek | $1,942 | Full coverage100/300/100, $1,000 deductible | 40-year-old unmarried male, clean, good credit | May 2026 |
| Compare.com | $2,076 | Full coverageLimits and deductible not stated | Not stated | Aug 2026 |
| The Zebra | $1,788 | Full coverageLimits and deductible not stated | 30-year-old male, no violations | No date |
| Insurance.com | $2,160$180/mo | Full coverage100/300/100, $500 deductible | 40-year-old, clean, good credit | Sep 2025 |
| CarEdge | $2,461 | Not stated | 40-year-old good driver, good credit, 13,000 mi/yr | No date |
| Insure.com | $2,656$221/mo | Full coverage100/300/100, $500 deductible | 40-year-old male, clean, good credit | Apr 2026 |
Read the coverage and the age before the number. Insurify blends coverage types across a fifty-year age band; Insure.com prices one 40-year-old on a $500 deductible. Methodology also varies — Insurify and Compare.com use real quote data, Insure.com and MoneyGeek use rate analysis, Insurance.com models synthetic rates.
The Insure.com methodology, for example, uses a 40-year-old male with a clean record and good credit, 100/300/100 liability limits, and a $500 comprehensive and collision deductible. Its figures are averaged across insurers and locations. Insurify's methodology is different: its headline $1,596 figure is an overall Explorer average, while its full-coverage average uses a $1,000 deductible.
Some publishers don't show their working at all. Freeway, Kelley Blue Book, SmartFinancial, and Edmunds publish Explorer insurance figures without saying who they priced. Those numbers can be useful as broad estimates, but they should not be treated as comprehensive quotes for the same hypothetical driver. Insurance companies can also price the same Explorer differently based on their own underwriting criteria, so comparing multiple insurers can help explain why published estimates and actual quotes may fall across a fairly wide range.
Comparing Full Coverage to Full Coverage
Like for Like
The two numbers people compare are not the same product
Insurify's headline figure and Insure.com's headline figure sit $1,060 apart. Line up what each one is actually pricing and most of that gap disappears.
Insurify
$1,596
per year, headline Explorer average
- Coverage
- Blended across all coverage types. Its own full-coverage figure is about $2,124.
- Deductible
- $1,000
- Liability limits
- State minimum up to $50,000 per person
- Driver
- An average across ages 20 to 70 — a population, not a person
Insure.com
$2,656
per year, full coverage
- Coverage
- Full coverage only
- Deductible
- $500
- Liability limits
- 100/300/100
- Driver
- One 40-year-old male, clean record, good credit
Compare full coverage with full coverage and the band is still wide. The Zebra $1,788, MoneyGeek $1,942, Compare.com $2,076, Insurance.com $2,160, Insure.com $2,656 — a 49% spread explained by deductible, liability limits and driver age.
At first glance, the published figures look like they disagree by hundreds of dollars a year. But not all of them measure the same thing. Once you line up the coverage, deductible, liability limits, and driver profile, the spread becomes much easier to understand.
Coverage level does part of the work, not all of it. Insurify's $1,596 headline figure blends coverage types. Its methodology separately puts full coverage at about $2,124 and liability-only coverage at about $1,068. Insure.com's $2,656 figure, by contrast, is full coverage. Comparing $1,596 with $2,656 therefore makes the disagreement look larger than it is. But comparing only the full-coverage figures still leaves a wide band: The Zebra at $1,788, MoneyGeek at $1,942, Compare.com at $2,076, Insurance.com at about $2,160, and Insure.com at $2,656 — a 49% spread. The three variables below account for the rest of it.
Deductible makes a difference, too. Insure.com and Insurance.com use a $500 deductible, while Insurify and MoneyGeek use $1,000. A higher deductible generally lowers the premium because the policyholder accepts more of the initial cost after a covered loss.
Liability limits aren't standardized either. Insure.com, Insurance.com, and MoneyGeek use 100/300/100 limits, while Insurify's full coverage definition permits bodily-injury limits ranging from state minimums to $50,000 per person. In other words, several publishers are calling different insurance products "full coverage."
Driver age is a major variable. Most of the published figures use a 40-year-old, but The Zebra uses a 30-year-old, and Insurify averages drivers from 20 to 70. That means Insurify's headline number describes a population rather than one actual driver. The Zebra's current Explorer page confirms its rate is based on a 30-year-old male with no violations.
Finally, quotes and modeled rates are not identical. Some publishers draw on real quotes served to shoppers, while others calculate rates using insurer filings or modeled driver profiles. Both approaches can be useful, but they answer slightly different questions.
Sometimes the same site gives you two answers. MoneyGeek lists the Explorer at $1,942 a year on its Explorer page and $1,355 on its vehicle hub. Both say full coverage, both use 100/300/100 limits and a $1,000 deductible, and the cheaper figure is actually the more recently updated of the two.
What separates them is who got priced: the $1,942 is a 40-year-old unmarried male with a clean record and good credit, while the $1,355 is only "an adult driver" with no age attached. Age moves an Explorer premium more than almost anything else on this page, so the figure with an age on it is the one quoted here.
Explorer Insurance Cost by Model Year
By Model Year
Newer Explorers cost more — both publishers agree on that
The two lines slope the same way across every model year. The vertical distance between them is the driver being priced, not the vehicle.
- Insure.com40-year-old male, clean record, good credit, 100/300/100, $500 deductible. Published 7 April 2026.
- The Zebra30-year-old male, full coverage, no violations. No publication date stated on the source page.
Read the line that matches your age. There is no single true number in the middle of the two. Covers 2015–2025 only — no 2026 figure with a stated driver profile exists yet.
Model year usually matters because newer vehicles tend to have higher replacement values and more expensive technology. Insure.com's 2026 table, for example, puts a 2025 Explorer at $2,656 annually and a 2015 model at $1,977 for its standardized full coverage driver. The Zebra's model-year data follows the same broad downward pattern for older vehicles.
The two tables below come from different publishers pricing different drivers, so they are shown separately. Averaging them would produce a number that describes nobody.
Insure.com estimates an annual full-coverage premium for a 40-year-old male driver with a clean record, good credit, 100/300/100 liability limits, and a $500 deductible, based on data published April 7, 2026.
By Model Year — Insure.com
Explorer cost by model year, one 40-year-old driver
Annual full-coverage premium for a 40-year-old male with a clean record and good credit, 100/300/100 limits and a $500 deductible. Published 7 April 2026.
| Model year | Annual full coverage |
|---|---|
| 2025 | $2,656 |
| 2024 | $2,618 |
| 2023 | $2,648 |
| 2022 | $2,560 |
| 2021 | $2,452 |
| 2020 | $2,413 |
| 2019 | $2,225 |
| 2018 | $2,178 |
| 2017 | $2,112 |
| 2016 | $2,051 |
| 2015 | $1,977 |
This table and the one below are not interchangeable. They price different drivers on different deductibles, so the gap between them is the driver, not the vehicle.
The Zebra provides an annual estimate based on a 30-year-old male driver with full coverage and no violations, but the page does not include a publication date.
By Model Year — The Zebra
The same question, priced for a 30-year-old
Annual full-coverage estimate for a 30-year-old male driver with no violations. The source page carries no publication date.
| Model year | Annual full coverage |
|---|---|
| 2025 | $2,283 |
| 2024 | $2,212 |
| 2023 | $2,151 |
| 2022 | $2,067 |
| 2021 | $2,028 |
| 2020 | $1,989 |
| 2019 | $1,878 |
| 2018 | $1,816 |
| 2017 | $1,737 |
| 2016 | $1,679 |
| 2015 | $1,628 |
| 2014 | $1,582 |
| 2013 | $1,535 |
| 2012–2011 | $1,486–$1,455 |
Watch for the cheapest-carrier numbers. The Zebra also publishes a Cheapest Insurance Companies table for each year. The $1,421 figure sometimes quoted for a 2020 Explorer comes from there, not from this column.
There is a common trap here. Alongside each model year, The Zebra also publishes a "Cheapest Insurance Companies" table listing individual carriers and their own average annual costs. Those carrier figures sit lower than the model-year average, and they are easy to mistake for it. The $1,421 figure sometimes quoted for a 2020 Explorer is one of those cheapest-carrier numbers, not the average for that year.
If you're shopping a 2026 Explorer, expect less data than you'd like. Insure.com and The Zebra both stop at the 2025 model year, and MoneyGeek's list ends there too. Compare.com does publish a 2026 figure — $168 a month — but with no driver profile, liability limits or deductible attached to it.
That number is also measuring something narrower than the $2,076 in the table above. The $2,076, or $173 a month, is Compare.com's average across every Explorer model year. The $168 is the 2026 line on its own. The two aren't interchangeable.
Until more 2026 rates are published, a 2025 Explorer premium is the closest useful benchmark — and a quote on your own ZIP code and driving record will beat either one.
For owners shopping by year, SaveMax's dedicated pages for the 2021 Ford Explorer insurance cost and 2022 Ford Explorer insurance cost provide a more focused comparison.
Why 2020 Explorer Estimates Disagree
The 2020 model year is the single most searched Explorer year, and it's also where the sources fall apart most dramatically. Insurify publishes $216 a month for a 2020 Explorer; MoneyGeek publishes $114. That's an 89% gap, and both figures were live as of August 2026. The rest of the field lands somewhere in between: Insure.com at $201/month, Insurance.com at $180/month, and ValuePenguin at $253/month (Texas only).
Three things are going on here:
Different products are being priced. Insurify's figure is an average monthly quote blended across all coverage types over a 50-year age band; MoneyGeek's is full coverage at a $1,000 deductible for one specific 40-year-old. These were never measuring the same thing.
Deductible and liability limits account for most of what's left between the two full-coverage numbers.
MoneyGeek's 2020 row sits oddly against its own neighboring years. Its neighboring years read 2019 at $169, 2020 at $114, then 2021 at $138 — a 33% drop followed by a rebound that no rating factor explains. Every other source's 2020 figure sits neatly between its 2019 and 2021 values. 2020 is also the year Ford fully redesigned the Explorer on a new platform, so "2020 Explorer" does not describe one completely uniform vehicle from a safety perspective.
In short, these aren't two estimates of the same thing: it's a blended average sitting against a figure that its own neighboring rows don't support. Insurify's model-year curve also rises smoothly across all thirteen years with no reversals, which may indicate a modeled series rather than one built from observed quotes.
Ford Explorer Insurance Cost by Trim
Trim-level insurance data is even less settled than model-year data. MoneyGeek and Insure.com both publish Explorer trim figures, but their results disagree sharply.
By Trim
Two publishers, two very different trim penalties
MoneyGeek prices the ST 41% above its own Explorer average. Insure.com prices it 2.6% above. Both are shown here because there is no responsible way to combine them.
| Trim | MoneyGeekMonthly, $1,000 deductible | Insure.comAnnual, $500 deductible |
|---|---|---|
| Active | $180 | $2,539 |
| ST-Line | $204 | $2,621 |
| Limited | $212 | Not published |
| Timberline | $220 | Not published |
| ST | $233 | $2,724 |
| Platinum | $238 | $2,726 |
| King Ranch | $244 | Not published |
| Explorer average | $165 | $2,656 |
Trim names changed in 2024. This table describes the current lineup. For a pre-2024 Explorer — XLT, XLS, Eddie Bauer or Sport — quote the specific vehicle by VIN rather than matching it to a name here.
MoneyGeek's figures use a 40-year-old unmarried male with a clean record, good credit, 100/300/100 limits, and a $1,000 deductible. Insure.com's figures use its 40-year-old male profile with 100/300/100 and a $500 deductible.
The difference is substantial. MoneyGeek prices the ST 41% above its own Explorer average, while Insure.com prices it only 2.6% above its average. There is no responsible way to combine those into one "true" ST premium.
MoneyGeek's trim table also contains duplicate-looking entries such as "ST Sport Utility 4d" and "ST," or "Limited Sport Utility 4d" and "Limited," with different prices. The naming may capture different model-year averages, but the table does not make that distinction sufficiently clear.
The vehicle itself provides a reason to expect trim differences. Ford's specifications put the Explorer range roughly from the Active at $38,465 and 300 horsepower to the ST at $56,700 and 385-400 horsepower. Ford and other automotive sources differ on the ST's exact output depending on configuration, so it is better to preserve that distinction than manufacture a single figure.
Hybrid trim figures should also be treated cautiously. MoneyGeek is the only source in this dataset pricing the hybrid trims, and its results come in lower than comparable gasoline trims. That is counterintuitive enough that the safer interpretation is a naming or model-year classification issue, not proof that a Hybrid Explorer is inherently cheaper to insure.
Trim names changed in 2024. The table above describes the current lineup. Explorers built before the 2024 refresh used a different ladder — XLT, XLS, Eddie Bauer and Sport among them — and XLT is the trim the used market is full of. MoneyGeek does price several of those older names, but not in a way you can act on: its table carries both "Xlt" at $174 a month and "Xlt Sport Utility 4d" at $154, with no model year attached to either, so there is no way to tell which era's XLT a given row describes. For a pre-2024 Explorer, quote the specific vehicle by VIN rather than matching it to a trim name.
Cheapest Insurers for a Ford Explorer
Which company comes out cheapest depends on which publisher you ask, because each one prices a different driver. What the sources agree on is the shortlist: USAA, State Farm, GEICO, American Family, and Travelers recur across all of them.
Insure.com's carrier table is the best documented of the group. It prices a 40-year-old male with a clean record and good credit, 100/300/100 limits, and a $500 deductible, drawn from rate filings rather than live quotes.
MoneyGeek puts GEICO first instead, at $129 a month for full coverage against an Explorer average of $162, with Travelers at $137 and State Farm at $160. Its profile is a 40-year-old unmarried male with a $1,000 deductible, and its table does not include USAA at all — which changes who finishes cheapest.
Three things matter more here than the ranking itself:
USAA is not open to everyone. It requires military, veteran, or eligible-family status, and it sits at or near the top of most Explorer rate tables. That can make the field look cheaper than it actually is for a civilian shopper.
Erie and Auto-Owners are regional. Erie writes in roughly a dozen states plus DC; Auto-Owners in about 26. Neither is available across the West Coast.
The order changes with the profile. American Family leads the $500-deductible table; GEICO leads the $1,000-deductible table. Neither is wrong — they are pricing different policies.
Among carriers available to most drivers, American Family and GEICO appear near the front of more than one publisher's list.
Compare Explorer quotes across insurers with SaveMax Auto.
Ford Explorer Insurance Cost by State
Where you park the Explorer moves the premium more than which trim you bought. Using Insure.com's state table — the same 40-year-old profile, 100/300/100 limits, and $500 deductible, published April 7, 2026 — the Explorer costs $4,508 a year in Louisiana and $1,555 in Hawaii. That is a $2,953 difference, roughly 2.9 times, for the same vehicle and the same driver.
By State
The same Explorer and the same driver, all fifty states
One driver priced in every state: a 40-year-old male with a clean record and good credit, 100/300/100 limits and a $500 deductible, driving 10,000 miles a year. Louisiana costs 2.9 times what Hawaii does.
| State | Annual full coverage | vs national average |
|---|---|---|
| 1.Louisiana | $4,508 | +$1,995 |
| 2.Nevada | $3,563 | +$1,050 |
| 3.Michigan | $3,549 | +$1,036 |
| 4.Washington, D.C. | $3,490 | +$977 |
| 5.California | $3,283 | +$770 |
| 6.Florida | $3,268 | +$755 |
| 7.Arkansas | $3,161 | +$648 |
| 8.South Carolina | $3,145 | +$632 |
| 9.Texas | $3,118 | +$605 |
| 10.Kentucky | $3,104 | +$591 |
| 11.Colorado | $3,097 | +$584 |
| 12.Oklahoma | $3,057 | +$544 |
| 13.Mississippi | $3,051 | +$538 |
| 14.New Jersey | $2,980 | +$467 |
| 15.Connecticut | $2,975 | +$462 |
| 16.Delaware | $2,951 | +$438 |
| 17.New York | $2,936 | +$423 |
| 18.Rhode Island | $2,892 | +$379 |
| 19.Maryland | $2,843 | +$330 |
| 20.South Dakota | $2,820 | +$307 |
| 21.Nebraska | $2,753 | +$240 |
| 22.Georgia | $2,752 | +$239 |
| 23.Arizona | $2,687 | +$174 |
| 24.Missouri | $2,601 | +$88 |
| 25.Pennsylvania | $2,587 | +$74 |
| 26.Kansas | $2,543 | +$30 |
| 27.Wisconsin | $2,500 | −$13 |
| 28.New Mexico | $2,482 | −$31 |
| 29.Alaska | $2,465 | −$48 |
| 30.Minnesota | $2,444 | −$69 |
| 31.West Virginia | $2,352 | −$161 |
| 32.Montana | $2,310 | −$203 |
| 33.Tennessee | $2,309 | −$204 |
| 34.North Carolina | $2,305 | −$208 |
| 35.Oregon | $2,284 | −$229 |
| 36.Illinois | $2,244 | −$269 |
| 37.Virginia | $2,240 | −$273 |
| 38.Iowa | $2,238 | −$275 |
| 39.Alabama | $2,233 | −$280 |
| 40.North Dakota | $2,156 | −$357 |
| 41.Utah | $2,110 | −$403 |
| 42.Massachusetts | $2,099 | −$414 |
| 43.Washington | $2,097 | −$416 |
| 44.Wyoming | $1,933 | −$580 |
| 45.Indiana | $1,792 | −$721 |
| 46.New Hampshire | $1,778 | −$735 |
| 47.Ohio | $1,758 | −$755 |
| 48.Idaho | $1,727 | −$786 |
| 49.Maine | $1,683 | −$830 |
| 50.Vermont | $1,670 | −$843 |
| 51.Hawaii | $1,555 | −$958 |
Ranked most to least expensive. The national full-coverage average on this same profile is $2,513 a year, so the third column is each state's distance from it. State averages are the least stable figures on this page — Compare.com, which states no driver profile, ranks Nevada among the cheapest states while this table ranks it second most expensive. Source: Insure.com, published 7 April 2026.
Larger states land in between: Texas $3,118, New York $2,936, Georgia $2,752, Pennsylvania $2,587, Illinois $2,244, Washington $2,097.
State rankings are the least stable figures on this page. Compare.com's Explorer state data, which states no driver profile, ranks Nevada among the cheapest states while Insure.com ranks it second most expensive. When two publishers disagree that sharply on one state, the profile behind the number is doing the work. Treat any state average as a starting point and quote your own ZIP code.
How Age, Driving Record and Credit Affect Your Rate
Age, record, and credit move an Explorer premium further than model year and trim combined.
Age. Insure.com prices an 18-year-old on the Explorer at $8,605 a year against its $2,656 adult baseline — about 3.2 times. Across all vehicles, MoneyGeek puts a 16-year-old at $7,962 and a 25-year-old at $4,606, against $1,506 for drivers aged 26 to 64. Drivers 65 and over average $1,884, about 25% above that band.
Driving record. Using MoneyGeek's 40-year-old, $1,000-deductible profile: an at-fault accident adds about $674 a year (46%), a speeding ticket 11-15 mph over adds about $374 (25%), and a DUI adds about $1,159 (77%).
Credit. MoneyGeek's credit analysis shows fair credit at $2,444 against $1,597 for good credit — a 53% difference — and poor credit at $5,435, about 240% higher. Four states bar insurers from using credit as an auto rating factor at all: California, Hawaii, Massachusetts, and Michigan. Maryland, Oregon, and Utah restrict it without banning it outright.
Apart from the Explorer-specific teen figure, the numbers above are all-vehicle averages. They show the size of each factor rather than what an Explorer will cost any one driver.
Ford Explorer vs Other SUVs
Comparing across vehicles only works inside one publisher. MoneyGeek prices every vehicle page on an identical profile — 40-year-old unmarried male, clean record, good credit, 12,000 miles a year, full coverage at 100/300/100 with a $1,000 deductible — which makes it the only clean like-for-like comparison available.
Against Other SUVs
Eight SUVs, one publisher, one driver
Comparing across vehicles only works inside a single publisher. MoneyGeek prices every vehicle page on an identical profile, which makes this the only clean like-for-like comparison available.
| Vehicle | Annual full coverage | Monthly |
|---|---|---|
| Ford Escape | $1,759 | $147 |
| Ford Edge | $1,823 | $152 |
| Honda Pilot | $1,824 | $152 |
| Ford ExplorerThis vehicle | $1,942 | $162 |
| Toyota Highlander | $2,103 | $175 |
| Jeep Grand Cherokee | $2,187 | $182 |
| Ford Bronco | $2,407 | $201 |
| Kia Telluride | $2,520 | $210 |
Chevrolet Traverse is missing on purpose. MoneyGeek publishes no Traverse page, and pulling that one figure from a publisher pricing a different driver would break the only thing that makes this table worth reading. Profile: 40-year-old unmarried male, clean record, good credit, 12,000 miles a year, full coverage at 100/300/100 with a $1,000 deductible.
The Explorer lands fourth of eight. It runs about $183 a year above the smaller Escape and $119 above the Edge, but $161 below the Highlander, $245 below the Grand Cherokee, $465 below the Bronco and $578 below the Telluride. MoneyGeek ranks it 60th of 256 SUVs for insurance affordability, and 258th of 827 vehicles overall.
One vehicle people compare against the Explorer is missing here: the Chevrolet Traverse. MoneyGeek publishes no Traverse page, and pulling that one figure from a different publisher pricing a different driver would break the only thing that makes this table worth reading.
Against the wider market, Compare.com and The Zebra both place the Explorer below the all-vehicle average. Compare.com puts Explorer full coverage at $173 a month against a $216 all-vehicle full-coverage average, and Explorer liability-only at $107 against $116. The direction is consistent across publishers and across both coverage levels; the size of the gap is not, so it is worth reading as a direction rather than a fixed figure.
Is the Explorer Above or Below the National Average?
Both, depending on which publisher you ask — and the disagreement is worth understanding.
Insure.com puts the national full-coverage average at $2,513 a year, priced on the same basis it uses for the Explorer: a 40-year-old with a clean record, 100/300/100 limits and a $500 deductible. Against its own $2,656 Explorer figure, that makes the Explorer about 6% more expensive than the average vehicle.
Compare.com reaches the opposite conclusion, placing the Explorer at $173 a month against a $216 all-vehicle national average — roughly 20% below average.
Two publishers, both measuring full coverage, disagreeing on whether a Ford Explorer costs more or less than the average vehicle. The reason is the one that runs through this entire page: their baselines are not the same product. Insure.com's average is built on a single standardized profile across nearly 30,000 cities; Compare.com's is a composite across many profiles. The useful conclusion is not a percentage but a position — the Explorer sits close enough to the middle of the market that no national comparison settles it, and your own quote will.
The same caution applies to the "cheapest SUV to insure" round-ups. Those lists commonly put the Honda CR-V at the top at $1,600 to $1,900 a year. Insure.com's own current CR-V page, priced on the same 40-year-old profile it uses for the Explorer, puts the CR-V at $2,401 — about 10% below the Explorer, not 40% below. Priced the same way, the distance between the cheapest mainstream SUV and a midsize three-row is far smaller than the round-ups suggest.
How to Lower Your Ford Explorer Insurance
Shop at renewal. MoneyGeek reports that Explorer owners who shop annually save up to 24% against those who let a policy auto-renew. Of everything on this list, this one costs nothing.
Raise the deductible if you can absorb it. Moving from $500 to $1,000 cuts the premium about 11% by Insure.com's measurement, or roughly $180 a year by The Zebra's. Carrier-level examples run from $143 to $350 saved annually. The trade is that you cover the first $1,000 of a covered loss.
Try usage-based tracking. Progressive's Snapshot reports average savings of $328. State Farm's Drive Safe & Save advertises up to 30%, though it isn't offered in California, Massachusetts, or Rhode Island.
Ask for the discounts carriers don't publish numbers for. Bundling, paid-in-full, low mileage, anti-theft, and defensive-driving credits are listed by most major insurers but not quantified, and their value varies by state. They are worth asking about at quote time.
Use student discounts if a teen drives the Explorer. State Farm's good-student discount runs up to 25% for a 3.0 GPA or better; Progressive's starts at 5%.
Consider dropping to liability-only on an older Explorer. Insurify puts Explorer liability-only at about $1,068 a year against roughly $2,124 for full coverage — a difference of about $1,056, or close to half the premium. On a 2015 Explorer, which Insure.com prices at $1,977 a year for full coverage, a single year of that coverage can approach a meaningful share of what the vehicle is worth. The trade is real: without collision and comprehensive, a total loss is yours to absorb.
What Drives Ford Explorer Insurance Costs
The Explorer's insurance record makes more sense when you look beyond the premium itself. Repair severity, recalls, and vehicle-level insurance losses all help explain why two apparently similar SUVs can produce different claims costs.
Why Explorer Repairs Cost More
The Explorer's average annual repair costs run about $732 against $573 for the midsize SUV segment and $652 across all vehicles — roughly 28% above its own segment. But it needs fewer trips there: 0.24 unscheduled shop visits a year, against 0.40 for both comparison groups.
That combination tells us that fewer visits paired with pricier ones is a severity pattern rather than a frequency one, and severity is what drives collision and comprehensive pricing more than how often something goes wrong. The probability of a severe repair sits at 14%, just slightly above the segment's 13%.
Part of the reason: the 2026 Explorer comes standard with blind spot detection, lane departure warning and prevention, rear automatic braking, and pre-collision assist — and every one of those sensors lives in a bumper, windshield, or mirror housing, which is exactly what a minor collision tends to destroy.
Repair cost and maintenance cost are different things, and only one of them affects your premium. On maintenance, the Explorer looks good — CarEdge estimates $3,105 over five years and $9,730 over ten, which it puts $725 and $1,218 below the SUV average over those periods, with a 27.5% chance of a major repair (one over $500) in the first ten years.
Cheap to maintain and expensive to repair is not a contradiction — it is the same severity-not-frequency pattern seen from the other side, and it is the repair half that insurers price.
Ford Explorer Recalls by Model Year
The Explorer carries a substantial recall history that most comparison pages don't touch. NHTSA's database shows campaigns by model year at 33 for 2020, 26 for 2021, 24 for 2022, 15 for 2023, 10 for 2024, 20 for 2025, and 11 for 2026 as of September 2026. 2020, the first year of the sixth-generation redesign, is the clear peak, and notably the same year the rate data above becomes unreliable. It's important to note that these numbers are not additive. One recall campaign can cover several model years.
Furthermore, three clusters stand out:
Rollaway and driveline issues — the signature defect group, spanning a 2020 driveshaft weld fracture, a 2023 rear axle bolt fracture, and a March 2025 recall covering Explorers whose earlier rear-axle repair was recorded as complete but never correctly performed.
Fire risk — via a 2024 engine failure campaign and a 2023 hybrid battery defect.
Rearview camera problems — eleven separate back-over-prevention campaigns across the model line, nine of which touch the 2020 model year alone.
Two campaigns remain live into 2026, covering second-row seats that can unlatch while driving and a transmission park pawl that may engage while moving.
Insurers do price in uncertainty about a model's claim tail, and a record like this is part of that picture — though no public source quantifies how much of an Explorer premium it accounts for.
Ford Explorer Theft Rates
Theft is one area where the Explorer's profile is more reassuring. HLDI's insurance-loss data estimated the Ford Explorer 4dr has a relative whole-vehicle-theft loss index of 7, 93% below average for 2022-24.
Collision losses are also below the all-vehicle benchmark. HLDI indexes midsize SUVs at 85 for collision and the Ford Explorer 4dr specifically at 87. The index is simple to interpret: 100 represents the average for all vehicles, so 87 means the Explorer's collision losses run 13% below average — noticeably fewer or cheaper collision claims than the typical insured vehicle. Property damage liability for midsize SUVs sits at 98, essentially at the all-vehicle norm.
Vehicle size still works in the other direction. HLDI's data shows property-damage liability losses generally rise with vehicle size, rising from 90 for small SUVs to 98 for midsize and 109 for very large SUVs. A heavier vehicle can cause more damage when it hits another vehicle or object.
So the Explorer is not a straightforward "high-theft SUV" story. Its insurance costs are shaped by a mixture of repair severity, crash losses, vehicle value, and driver factors rather than theft alone.
Ford Explorer Safety Ratings
The 2026 Ford Explorer earns an IIHS Top Safety Pick award. It receives Good ratings for the small-overlap front, updated moderate-overlap front, and updated side tests, along with good ratings for headlights, pedestrian front crash prevention, and seat-belt reminders. LATCH ease of use is rated Acceptable.
That's particularly useful for used Explorer shoppers, because "2020 Explorer" isn't one uniform vehicle. Ford made build changes during the model year that can result in meaningfully different crash-test outcomes, so the vehicle's build date can matter just as much as the model year listed on the title.
IIHS says structural changes made to the Explorer's left and right subframe on vehicles manufactured after May 2020 improved occupant protection in the small-overlap frontal crash. The later-built vehicles received an overall Good rating in that test.
In practical terms, a buyer comparing two 2020 Explorers should check the build date rather than assuming every vehicle from that model year has identical crash performance.
Compare the Rate, Not Just the Average
The published Explorer insurance numbers are not wrong simply because they disagree. They are answering different questions. A $1,596 average built from mixed coverage types is not directly comparable with Insure.com's $2,656 full-coverage estimate for a defined 40-year-old driver.
The more useful takeaway is that coverage level, deductible, driver profile, location, and insurer can move your premium substantially before the trim badge even enters the calculation.
If you're buying or already own an Explorer, use published averages as a starting point rather than a quote. Then compare rates using your actual model year, trim, location, driving record, and coverage needs.
FAQs About Ford Explorer Insurance
How Much Is Insurance on a Ford Explorer?
About $2,656 a year for full coverage for a 40-year-old male with a clean record and good credit, 100/300/100 limits, and a $500 deductible, according to Insure.com, updated April 7, 2026. Published figures range from $1,596 to $2,656, but the low end blends coverage types. Full-coverage estimates alone still run from $1,788 to $2,656 — about 49% — because deductible, driver age, and methodology vary by publisher. Liability-only coverage runs closer to $1,068 a year.
How Much Is Insurance on a 2020 Ford Explorer?
Published answers range from $114 to $253 a month. Insure.com reports $201, Insurance.com $180, The Zebra $166, and ValuePenguin $253 for Texas. The $114 MoneyGeek figure is unusual because its own neighboring years show $169 for 2019, $114 for 2020, and $138 for 2021. The Explorer was fully redesigned for 2020, and IIHS notes structural changes after May 2020, making build date relevant to this model year.
Which Ford Explorer Model Years Have the Worst Recall Records?
2020, by a wide margin. NHTSA's database shows 33 separate recall campaigns for the 2020 Explorer, against 26 for 2021, 24 for 2022, 15 for 2023, 10 for 2024, 20 for 2025 and 11 for 2026 as of September 2026. 2020 was the first year of the sixth-generation redesign, and it is also the model year where published rate estimates disagree most. Recall volume does not enter a quote directly — insurers price the vehicle and the driver, not the campaign count. What it does affect is the chance of buying a used Explorer with an unresolved campaign still open on it, which is worth checking against the VIN before a policy starts.
How Much More Is Ford Explorer ST Insurance?
The answer depends on the source. MoneyGeek prices the ST at $233 a month for full coverage against an Explorer average of $165, or about 41% more. Insure.com puts the ST at $2,724 a year against its $2,656 Explorer average, or about 2.6% more. Both sources use different methodologies and deductibles, so the figures should not be combined. The underlying vehicle difference is clearer: the ST costs roughly $18,000 more than the Active and produces substantially more power.
Is the Ford Explorer Expensive to Repair?
Yes, per repair visit, although it needs fewer unscheduled visits. Its average annual repair cost is about $732, versus $573 for midsize SUVs and $652 across all vehicles. It averages 0.24 unscheduled visits annually versus 0.40 for both comparison groups. That combination points to higher repair severity rather than unusually frequent breakdowns. For insurance, the cost of a covered repair can matter more than how often the vehicle visits a shop.
Do Ford Explorers Get Stolen a Lot?
Not compared with vehicles overall. HLDI's 2022-2024 theft data indexes midsize SUV theft losses at 50, against an all-vehicle average of 100 — roughly half. The Ford Explorer 4dr itself indexes at 7, about 93% below average. Collision losses for the Explorer are indexed at 87, where 100 is the all-vehicle average. Size creates a counterpoint: property damage liability losses tend to increase as vehicles get larger, because heavier vehicles can cause more damage in a crash. In other words, theft does not appear to be the main reason Explorer insurance costs what it does.